The Shopping Habit Behind Rising Apparel Return Rates
Open a lot of closets right now, and you’re likely to find the same story: three sizes of the same dress, two colors of the same sweater. One that's staying, the others already destined for a box back to the merchant. It's a habit apparel shoppers know well, even having a name for it, bracketing, and it explains a lot about why return rates in this category look the way they do.
TL; DR
- Many apparel shoppers order multiple sizes or colors of the same item, planning to keep only one and return the rest.
- This habit, sometimes called bracketing, is a rational response to inconsistent sizing across brands and the convenience of shopping from home.
- High return rates in apparel are often a predictable byproduct of this behavior, not a sign of poor product quality or policies.
- Once brands accept some orders are never meant to be kept, the opportunity shifts to turning a return into an exchange rather than a lost sale.
A Rational Workaround, Not Carelessness
Bracketing, as it's sometimes called, isn't a shopper being careless. It's a rational workaround for a problem the industry hasn't solved: sizing that varies from brand to brand and sometimes even from one collection to the next within the same brand. Ordering a small, medium, and large, then returning what doesn't fit, is often faster, especially given shipping times, than guessing once and hoping.
A Predictable Pattern, Not a Failure
After identifying the pattern of bracketing, ecommerce returns tell a different story than the raw numbers suggest. A rising return rate isn't automatically a verdict on product quality or on a policy that's too generous; some share of every order in this category was probably never meant to be kept in the first place, ordered as one option among a few rather than as a final decision.
Where the Real Opportunity Sits
Once this is the starting assumption, the real opportunity shifts downstream to what happens after the box is returned. A good return platform for online stores treats a return as an opportunity to offer the size or color that should have shipped the first time, not merely a request to process it.
Where the Best Tools Show a Real Gap
Here’s where the gap between tools becomes clear. The Shopify returns and exchanges app doesn't stop at issuing a refund; it's built to turn a bracketed order's return into a kept sale rather than a lost one, whether by offering store credit or using AI to recommend a 1:1 exchange.
About Redo
Redo helps ecommerce brands turn a return into a chance to keep the sale, using AI to recommend personalized exchanges, automate return and claim review, and surface insights into why items come back, all inside one branded returns and claims portal.
Explore how Redo turns returns into exchanges at https://redo.com/