How to Decide Who Handles Returns and Claims Next Year

January brings a wave of returned holiday gifts and exchange requests, and with it a question many growing brands put off: who should own the work?

For many teams, it's really two decisions.

One covers your returns, from the first review to the warehouse shelf. The other covers claims, such as orders that arrive damaged or never show up. A returns company can support you either way.

Here's how to decide which setup fits your team’s operations.

Illustrated figure walking between towering stacks of shipping containers in a stylized logistics facility.

Keep Returns In-House with Smarter Tools

Teams that want more control can still skip the busywork. A branded returns portal for Shopify lets you set the look, messaging, policies, and workflows your shoppers see. Behind it, AI weighs each request's photos, your shopper's past orders, and your policies before recommending a decision.

Your team still makes the calls that need judgment, while the software clears the routine ones first.

Industrial alley lined with stacked shipping containers and storage units beneath a clear blue sky.

Hand Off Receiving and Restocking

If you'd rather hand off receiving and restocking entirely, an entirely managed option moves that work into the provider's warehouse network. Returns get received, verified, and graded there, while a live view of inventory tells you which items are ready to sell again.

Your team keeps complete visibility and gets its stockroom back. This model suits brands with steady return volume and limited space, and it puts more of your team's time toward the shoppers and products that grow your business.

Large warehouse with multi-level storage platforms, inventory boxes, and workers managing logistics operations.

Choose Who Handles Your Claims

Claims follow their own workflow, and holiday shipping volume makes the choice of owner matter more. With the best Shopify returns app, you can pick one of two paths for claims: hand claims to the provider and share the revenue, or handle claims in-house and keep all of it.

Both paths work. Handing claims off protects a lean team's hours, while keeping them in-house gives you complete control along with the full revenue.

About Redo

Redo is an ecommerce operations platform that helps more than 5,000 brands turn the moments after checkout into revenue. Their AI-driven Returns & Claims portal reviews returns and claims automatically, recommends personalized exchanges, and turns return data into product-level insights. Eligible brands can also offer box-free drop-off at Happy Returns locations, while Redo's free Order Editing tool lets Shopify shoppers change their own orders before they ship. Oversee order tracking, fulfillment, and AI-powered marketing in the same system.

Find the returns setup that fits your team at https://redo.com/

Popular posts from this blog

What a Bad Return Policy Really Costs DTC Brands Beyond the Refund

Why Your Online Return Platform Shouldn’t Be an Afterthought

Before and After: How AI Replaces the Cluttered Returns Inbox